






Wednesday, June 3, 2009
Dear Friends and Supporters of David Goldman,
As you may know Brazilian Federal Judge Rafael de Souza Pereira Pinto issued a ruling Monday the 1st ordering the return of Sean Goldman to the United States in 48 hours. It was an extraordinary ruling in every sense.
David left for Brazil Monday evening to be reunited with Sean and bring Sean home today, Wednesday June 3rd.
There has been a major and shocking development. The New York Times, reported that on Tuesday evening "...Marco Aurelio Mello, one of 11 (Brazilian) Supreme Court justices, suspended the sentence after receiving a request from Brazil’s Progressive Party, which argued that ordering the child to be sent to the United States was unconstitutional. The Supreme Court must now take up the case, but it was unclear when that would happen." The Times also quoted Bernard Aronson, a former United States assistant secretary of state for Latin America who is advising David Goldman.
“Brazil needs to define itself as either a nation of laws or a nation that harbors and protects child abductors,...”
We still do not have all the facts surrounding this order, whether or not an uninvolved political party can even appeal a Federal judge's decision under Brazilian law. We are now told that the 11 member Supreme Court will vote on the appeal next Wednesday June 10th. If this appeal succeeds, basically rejecting Brazil's sovereign obligation under the Hague Convention, it endangers all of the 70 American children and countless more from other countries who have been abducted to and harbored in Brazil. As Mr. Aronson bluntly stated above, we too can only wonder if Brazil will allow this to happen and deny this father and son their fundamental right to be together.
We have no animosity towards Brazil and its nearly 200 million citizens. Today we have been receiving emails from hundreds and hundreds of Brazilians and Brazilian-Americans, this single one is representative of the very same sentiments expressed in all of them:
"Some group of Politicians got a new order from a Federal Judge changing the sentence about Sean come back to USA. I couldn't believe this happen. I am so disappointed and furious...and I ashamed to be Brazilian. I'm so sorry."
NBC's Today Show aired an update on the events of the last 48 hours on Wednesday, You can view the video at: http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/26184891/#31080439
Dateline NBC which traveled to Brazil with David has tentatively announced that it will be airing a complete one hour report on the Goldman case on Sunday June 7th at 10:00 p.m. Eastern, 9:00 p.m. Central. For supporters in the Mountain andPacific time zones please check your local listings for the channel and correct time.The situation in Brazil is FLUID, please check the FORUMS on thewww.BringSeanHome.org website for any breaking news on the case.
There is an excellent synopsis of the events of the past three days on the Asbury Park Press website. The article Congressman: Father visited with son in Brazil was written by Bill Handelman.
Radio station NJ 101.5 (FM) is scheduled to air a taped interview withCongressman Chris Smith on Thursday the 4th. Unfortunately we do not know the time of interview will be aired. NJ 101.5 streams their broadcasts online: http://www.nj1015.com/
WE WILL NEVER GIVE UP!
Friends of David Goldman
* Judge in Brazil Stays Order for Boy’s Return to U.S. The New York Times

Poor Evie thinks she is being nice to her!
