Over Christmas break Enzo and I decided to try and call the US consulate in Sao Paulo to discuss Enzo's mother's visa denial. I wanted to talk to them. So upon calling I decided I was not going to get mad. I was going to remain calm. Well they kept giving me the run around and they would even hang up on me! They were completely rude. I almost even asked if I could speak to an American citizen because they all had Brazilian accents (not that that means they are bad people because they are Brazilian but I don't think it is fair that I pay my taxes and then I am told off by someone who not only doesn't even live in the US but isn't a citizen..with regarding immigration matters!!!)
So this week came and Enzo decided to call himself. They were nicer to him (maybe because he is Brazilian, who really knows) but they told him the only accept questions via email (which by the way... it wasn't like this 3 years ago when we were getting Enzo into the country). I looks like once again there is no real answer to our questions and we are right back where we started. If anyone knows someone who can help please let us know. We would really like Enzo's mother be able to see our lives here.
So...now he began the writing. Here are the emails:
Email #1 (From Enzo)From: Enzo
Sent: Tuesday, January 27, 2009 3:58 PM
To: Visa, Sao_Paulo
Subject: Re: Request to review my mother's visa application - (Enzo's mom's name went here )
Hi,
it's been a while since I've last talked to a (very cordial) officer at your visa department about my mother's case.
My wife (American citizen) and I are about to have our baby (due date February 26) and it has been a joyful time for all of us. There is one thing bothering us though: my mother not being able to be present to enjoy all this change and happiness with us for a few days or months when/after Evelyn is born.
I would like to ask for clarification on why exactly she didn't obtain a tourist visa (we fully understand there is no such thing as a "visitor" visa, but we would like to make it clear that we WOULD do tourism with her in the U.S. and show her different places in the country while she stays with us for the duration of her visa).
We have NO intentions whatsoever (and neither does she) of overstaying a visa, working illegally, etc. We all all very honest people and can prove income to be able to sponsor her in all aspects of her trip. Although she is poor, she is elderly and WILL NOT commit any illegal acts here or in Brazil (she has never done so, for that matter).
Please reconsider this decision of denying her a visa. All we want is a few days or months for her to be with us and we will pay for all expenses to/from the United States .
Thank you.
Enzo Silva wrote:
I sent this email a while ago and am worried it hasn't reached you, since haven't received any response yet.
Thank you.
Email #2 (response from US consulate)Visa, Sao_Paulo wrote:
Dear Mr. Silva,
Thank you for your email message regarding your interest in the issuance of a non-immigrant visa for your mother (insert Enzo's mother's name).
We recommend Mrs. Silva bring a copy of your e-mail message as well as documentation demonstrating her social, financial, and professional ties to Brazil when she appears here for her visa application interview.
We want to assure you that, as in the past, her visa application will be given every consideration consistent with United States immigration laws and regulations and that all appropriate courtesies will be extended.
We hope this information has been useful in responding to your inquiry. Please do not hesitate to contact us if we can be of further assistance on this or any other matter.
Best regards,
Consulado Geral dos Estados Unidos – São Paulo, Brasil
Setor de Vistos de Não-Imigrantes
Informações gerais sobre visto
¿ www.consuladoamericanosp.org.br
É (11) 5186.7000
* visasaopaulo@state.gov
Agendamento de entrevista
¿ www.visto-eua.com.br
É (21) 4004.4950 / (21) 2108.9199
Email #3 (From Enzo)From: Enzo
Sent: Wednesday, January 28, 2009 12:52 PM
To: Visa, Sao_Paulo
Subject: Re: Request to review my mother's visa application - (insert Enzo's mother's name)
Thank you for taking the time to review my emails. However, I have a few follow-up questions.
As for right now, my mother does not have an interview date.
She has already been denied so I don't know if it would help to interview again since her circumstances have not changed. She doesn't have cars, homes, land and other possessions (that would prove wealth as a tie to Brazil by any means).
What ties would be important other than financial ones?
Also, in my mom's case, would you recommend for her to try another tourist visa?
Also, you recommended for my mother to bring along a copy of the email below.
From my own personal experience and from my mother's as well, when she has previously been interviewed for a tourist visa the interviewee did not give her the opportunity to show documents such as these.
What is your recommendation in situations like this?
Again, thank you so much for taking the time to read through my questions and for replying promptly.
ENZO SILVA.
Email #4 (response from US Consulate)Dear Mr. Silva,
We can not assert that the next time your mother appears for her interview she will be approved or not. If she doesn’t have any strong ties it will be inflexible for her to obtain a tourist visa. We recommend her the next time she appears at the Consulate to bring all the documents that proofs she will return to her origin country. She can also bring a support letter written by you.
Wishes of Good Luck.
Please, read the pamphlet regarding a little about visa denials.
Consulado Geral dos Estados Unidos – São Paulo, Brasil
Setor de Vistos de Não-Imigrantes
Informações gerais sobre visto
¿ www.consuladoamericanosp.org.br
É (11) 5186.7000
* visasaopaulo@state.gov
Agendamento de entrevista
¿ www.visto-eua.com.br
É (21) 4004.4950 / (21) 2108.9199